Pages

Latin Compounding

The idea that the Latin language itself is (or was) ill-suited to prolific formation of compounds of the kind found in Greek is hooey. Ancient Roman linguistic preferences do not exhaust the possibilities of the language itself.

Quintilian's value judgment:

Sed res tota magis Graecos decet, nobis minus succedit, nec id fieri natura puto, sed alienis favemus; ideoque cum κυρταύχενα mirati simus, incurvicervicum vix a risu defendimus.

(But all this suits the Greeks better. It has not caught on so much with us — not I think because of any innate property, but rather we favor loanwords and so admire κυρταύχενα whereas we can hardly keep from ridiculing "incurvicervicum")
 
Should not be interpreted to be an inexorable result of something intrinsic to the Latin language, as when one scholar suggested that "nominal compounding is not as developed in Latin as it is in other IE languages, since the prototypical length of Latin words is rather short".

The fact that, at least during the empire, Roman-era Latin was not especially given to creative compounds reflects less a linguistic property of Latin than the aesthetic and cultural judgments of those Latin writers whose works survived transmission from antiquity.

 I strongly suspect that resistance to innovative compounding in Latin was BECAUSE it was so associated with Greek, and thus was especially liable to strike the tender nerves of Roman linguistic insecurity. Some words from early Latin tragedy coined on Greek models (sonipes, flexanimo) got entrenched early enough to be grandfathered in.

Some Late Republican writers did coin freely when they wanted to. I think it's no accident that they tend to have been either (a) rather experimentally uninhibited in their Hellenizing or (b) in operating genres held in low esteem by the Roman literary elite. A single poem by Catullus contains such interesting items as hederiger (ivory-bearing), nemorivagus (grove-rover), silvicultrix (forest-tending), erifuga (master-fleeing). And this by no means exhausts the list of Catullan compounds. In the fragments attributed to Decimus Laberius, who worked in a low-prestige genre, there are 46 hapax legomena, and many of these too are obvious compound words. Three nonce-compounds to describe a bull (testitrahus, reciprocicornis, lanicutis) all occur in a single fragment of his. Both the Catullan examples, and those of Laberius, (and even more so comparable coinages found in Lucretius and the fragments of Accius) seem to be inspired by Greek precedent.

Glosses of Greek terms often contain as explanations perfectly serviceable compounds which simply seem not to have caught on in recorded latin. For example πλατυλόγος in one gloss is explained as "latiloquens", which — though a hapax word — is not just perfectly intelligible, but probably near-idiomatic given that that the adverb "late" qualifying verbs of speaking (including loqui itself) was no stranger to the language of Cicero or Quintilian, and that "lati-" as a compounding theme itself is well-attested in words like "laticlavium" and "latifolius."

That "latiloquens" never caught on in accepted literary usage probably has little to do with inherent unsuitability. There is no intrinsic reason why literary Latin could not have taken such a Greek lexical technique over wholesale, much as it did Greek metrical and generic conventions. That it did not do so is an accident of cultural history, and has little to do with the kinds of lexemes the Latin Language itself can or cannot withstand.

10 comments:

  1. best dentist in Scarborough
    Dr. Salim Kapadia Dental Centre is a patient-centred certified best dental office near Markham Road in Scarborough. Using the latest dental technologies, our team delivers quality dental services. We give our patients personalized attention and we value long term relationships with our patients. We are one of the most affordable dentist in Scarborough, Ontario.

    ReplyDelete
  2. We carry 8000 titles of Hip Hop
    Big mens clothing is important to fit a man that needs larger sizes such as 3x,4x,5x,6x.

    ReplyDelete

  3. news al arabia

    An in depth coverage of local global breaking news offering live reports on the latest political, economic, social, and cultural affairs only on Al Arabiya

    ReplyDelete


  4. breaking news headlines today

    Find the latest breaking news and information on the top stories, weather, business, entertainment, politics, and more For in depth coverage, Bd Portal 24 provides special reports, video, audio, photo galleries, and interactive guides

    ReplyDelete

  5. reverse text

    Convert your text in many styles with small text generator tool online. Styling including bubble letters, tiny text, upside down text, reverse text, tiny font, etc. Try Text Tools now!

    ReplyDelete
  6. SanoMed Pharmacy & Compounding Centre offers fast, reliable and customized compounding services. They also offer prescription transfer, prescription fill, refill and free delivery within Toronto! This is your go-to pharmacy in Downtown Toronto for Covid-19 Vaccination, Rapid Antigen Test & Rapid Antibody Test.

    compounding pharmacy

    ReplyDelete
  7. dark web links

    There are many merits of dark web links, in fact it is one of the main reasons why you should prefer them. In fact it is not only about the Google ranking as it can affect your site's online visibility as well. The Googlebot can detect these links with special codes, and in this case when you have links coming from these kinds of sources, then your site's ranking will improve. This is because the links are closer to the visitors, and they tend to read and click more easily than a link coming straight from the homepage.

    ReplyDelete
  8. jasa bikin logo

    Jasa desain logo Kami bisa membantu Anda dalam merancang sebuah logo sesuai dengan permintaan. Setiap pengerjaan pembuatan logo akan selalu kami maksimalkan agar memuaskan.
    Kami hadir di Indonesia sebagai penyedia layanan jasa pembuatan desain logo profesional. Kami menawarkan jasa bikin logo sesuai konsep permintaan yang di 100% original oleh tim desain yang sudah ahli dibidangnya.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Your blog is very popular, so many people told me to read your blog. Today I read this blog. I am very happy to read your blog today.Check out Dental Compounding Pharmacy

    ReplyDelete
  10. pc repair near me

    Trueonefix Computer Repair Service acts solution-oriented. Our personnel serving in our computer technical service workshop have the same opinion as us.

    We are Tampa Florida's computer repair shop offering the best in service, price and quality. Our prices are competitive with our competitors because we don't have franchise fees or expensive advertising expenses.

    Sometimes we can encounter problems that keep us busy for hours. For example, our customer brings us a defective laptop for repair. The problem is that a small circuit on the motherboard is burned and therefore the device does not work. As you know, the most difficult task in repair work is to find the source of the problem. Getting down to the source of the problem and finding it in a short time is possible with the experience that can be obtained after years of work.

    ReplyDelete